top of page
Search
Writer's pictureTaylor Burnham

Should I Pay Someone an Early Settlement if I Cause a Car Accident and Don’t Have Car Insurance in Louisiana?

Updated: Dec 4

A photo of cars in the street

One minute you're just driving along, and the next thing you know - you're dealing with all this stress and confusion. On top of the car accident itself, now you've got to figure out how to pay for everything. It's a lot to handle, and it's totally normal to feel overwhelmed.


The good news is, you're not alone. Tons of people find themselves in this kind of situation, and they're trying to figure out what to do too. Maybe you're even wondering if you should try to work out a settlement with the other person involved. That could be an option, but navigating it can also be tricky.


The most important thing is to know that you've got choices. So, don't panic. Take a deep breath, and know that there are ways to get through this. With a little bit of help, you can figure out the best path forward and get back on your feet. 


You Caused a Car Accident Without Car Insurance


When you’re in a car accident and don’t have car insurance, things can become complicated very quickly. If you’re at fault, you may need to pay for damages and medical bills out of your own pocket. The other party has the right to seek compensation, which might mean paying for repairs, covering hospital bills, or even paying for time they missed at work.


In Louisiana, driving without insurance can also lead to severe consequences beyond just financial payments. You may face fines, penalties, and even criminal charges depending on the circumstances of the car accident.


If you’re the at-fault driver and lack car insurance, the financial burden can be steep. Without coverage, you’re left responsible for handling the costs of property damage, medical bills, and any other expenses resulting from the car accident. A car accident attorney can be valuable here—they can work with you to reduce these expenses and seek a fair settlement with the other party.


The Other Party is Seeking Compensation


After a car accident, the other driver will likely want compensation for their losses. They may file a claim through their insurance or decide to sue you directly. If they go through their insurance, their insurer might try to recoup costs from you later. In either case, you’ll need to respond. This could involve negotiating a settlement or preparing to defend yourself in court.


Consequences of Not Having Car Insurance After a Car Accident


If you drive a car in Louisiana without insurance, there are some serious consequences. Here’s what can happen:


  1. Fines: If you're caught driving without insurance, you might have to pay a fine. This can be anywhere from $500 to $1,000. The amount depends on whether it’s your first time getting caught or not.

  2. Losing Your License: You could lose your driver’s license if you don’t have insurance. This means you won’t be able to legally drive until it’s reinstated. Your car registration might also get canceled, and the police could take your car away.

  3. Accidents and No Pay, No Play: Louisiana has a rule called "No Pay, No Play" under the La. R.S. § 32:866. This means if you get into a car accident and don’t have insurance, you can’t get money for damages or injuries from the other driver’s insurance—even if the car accident wasn’t your fault. You would miss out on getting help for up to $25,000 in property damage and $15,000 for personal injuries.

  4. Reinstatement Fees: If your license gets suspended because you didn’t have insurance, you will have to pay extra fees to get it back later.


Car Insurance Laws and Penalties


Every state in the U.S., except New Hampshire and Virginia, requires drivers to carry auto insurance. If you don’t have coverage, the fines and penalties can increase if you’re involved in an accident. In Louisiana, this is even stricter due to the No Pay No Play law.


Louisiana's No Pay No Play Rule


The "No Pay, No Play" law is found in Louisiana Revised Statute 32:866:

"There shall be no recovery for the first fifteen thousand dollars of bodily injury and no recovery for the first twenty-five thousand dollars of property damage based on any cause or right of action arising out of a motor vehicle accident, for such injury or damages occasioned by an owner or operator of a motor vehicle involved in such accident who fails to own or maintain compulsory motor vehicle liability security.”

In Louisiana, every driver is required to have at least a minimum amount of insurance coverage. This includes:


  • $15,000 for injuries to one person

  • $30,000 for injuries to multiple people in one accident

  • $25,000 for damage to someone else's property


If you are driving without insurance and you get into an accident, this law limits how much money you can get back for your injuries or damages, even if the other driver is at fault (meaning they caused the accident).


How Does It Work?


Here’s how the law affects an uninsured driver:


  • If you are injured in an accident and you don’t have insurance, you cannot collect the first $15,000 for your medical treatment or bills.

  • You also cannot collect the first $25,000 for damage to your car or other property.


Example


Let’s say you’re driving without insurance and you get into an accident caused by another driver. You have $20,000 in medical treatment bills from your injuries and your vehicle damage costing $30,000. Because of the "No Pay, No Play" law:


  • You can only claim $5,000 of your medical expenses because you can’t get the first $15,000.

  • For your vehicle damage, you can only claim $5,000 of the $30,000 because of the $25,000 limit.


This means that even though your total expenses are $50,000, you would only be able to recover $10,000. The rest would come out of your own pocket.


Louisiana's No Pay No Play Rule Exceptions


A picture of a stoplight

While Louisiana’s No Pay No Play rule generally applies, there are some exceptions. For instance, if you’re a pedestrian or a passenger, this rule may not affect your ability to accident claim damages. It’s best to check with a local attorney for specific situations, as they can help clarify these exceptions.


Penalties for Driving Without Car Insurance From A Car Insurance Company


Driving without car insurance in Louisiana can lead to serious consequences. Penalties may include:


  • Fines – These can range from several hundred to a few thousand dollars.

  • License Suspension – The DMV may suspend your license for a set period.

  • Criminal Charges – In certain cases, you may face criminal charges, especially if there were injuries involved.


Consequences of Not Having Insurance Coverage From An Insurance Company


Without car insurance, you’re vulnerable to both financial and legal consequences. Beyond having to pay for damages and medical costs, you may also face additional legal penalties and potential lawsuits, which could further complicate your situation.


Options for the At-Fault Driver


If you’re the at-fault driver without insurance, consider exploring all options that may reduce your liability. For instance, check if any car insurance policy applies, even indirectly.


  • Employment Coverage – If you are an at-fault driver and working at the time, your employer may have coverage that applies.

  • Marital or Family Coverage – If you’re married, your spouse may have insurance that includes you. Similarly, if you live with family members, their policy could potentially cover you through resident relative coverage.


Explore Resident Relative Coverage


Resident relative coverage refers to a type of insurance protection that extends to certain family members living with you. This can include your spouse, children, siblings, or other relatives who share your home. The key point is that these individuals are considered "resident relatives" under most auto insurance policies, meaning they may be covered even if they are not specifically named on the policy.


For example, if you live with your brother and you have car insurance, your brother could potentially be covered under your policy if he gets into an accident while driving your car. This coverage is important because it can provide financial help for medical bills or damages caused by an accident.


Uninsured or Underinsured Driver Motorist Coverage


In Louisiana, drivers are encouraged to carry uninsured or underinsured driver motorist coverage, though it’s optional. This insurance can cover damages if the other driver lacks insurance or doesn’t carry enough to cover the costs. If the other driver was hurt, they might be able to seek compensation through their own uninsured motorist coverage.


Paying an Early Settlement to the Other Party


One way to manage the financial impact is to negotiate an early settlement with the other driver. This can prevent a drawn-out legal battle and may reduce overall costs. If you choose this route, ensure the settlement amount covers all damages and is fair to both parties.


What to Offer as an Early Settlement to the Other Party


When offering a settlement, consider the following:


  • Property Damage – Obtain a clear estimate of the damage. If it’s reasonable, consider offering to cover this out of pocket.

  • Medical Expenses – Medical bills can add up quickly, especially if there were injuries. Some insurers offer between $1,500 and $4,500, plus medical bills, to settle an injury claim early. This might be a helpful range to consider when negotiating.


Finalizing the Settlement


Personal Injury Lawyer Taylor Burnham talking to his client about the finalization of a settlement

Once you and the other party agree on the terms, make sure to get everything in writing. An email exchange can often serve as sufficient documentation if it clearly shows an offer and acceptance of the settlement terms. 


"A compromise is a contract whereby the parties, through concessions made by one or more of them, settle a dispute or an uncertainty concerning an obligation or other legal relationship."

A compromise (settlement) is binding when both parties agree to the terms. Additionally, you may want the other party to sign a Release of All Claims document, formally ending any future claims against you.


Filing a Lawsuit Against the At-Fault Driver


If you are involved in a car accident and you are the one at fault, there is a possibility that the other party may decide to file a lawsuit against you. This can be a stressful situation, but it’s important to know your rights and how to defend yourself effectively.


When faced with a lawsuit, it’s crucial to take it seriously. You will need to defend yourself in court, which can be complicated without proper legal knowledge. A car accident defense lawyer can be an invaluable resource in this situation. They can help you navigate the legal process, understand the claims against you, and work towards ensuring a fair outcome.

One of the most important things to remember is that you must respond to the lawsuit in a timely manner. If you fail to do so, the court may issue a default judgment against you.


A default judgment means that the court automatically rules in favor of the other party because you did not respond or show up for your court date. This could lead to serious financial consequences, including having to pay damages without having your side of the story heard.


Avoiding Future Complications


Attorney Taylor Burnham on his way to meet with a client

Being in an accident, especially without insurance, is overwhelming. You’re not only dealing with the emotional shock but also the stress of potential financial and legal consequences. It’s easy to feel anxious and uncertain about what to do next.


At Burnham Law Firm, we understand the weight of this situation and the unique struggles that come with it, particularly if the other party is seeking compensation. Many people in this position feel trapped or unsure, and it’s okay to ask for help in navigating the steps ahead.


Taking action can make a big difference in easing some of the burden. If you need help, reach out to us today for a FREE consultation and we will point you in the right direction

Comments


bottom of page