Can Babies Count as Passengers in the HOV Lane?

High-Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) lanes are designed to ease traffic congestion by encouraging carpooling. However, drivers sometimes try to bend the rules, leading to some creative—and illegal—attempts to meet the occupancy requirement. 

A notable incident occurred in Arizona when a driver attempted to use a baby doll as a "second person" to gain access to the HOV lane. While the story made headlines and drew some laughs, it also raises serious questions about who actually qualifies as a "passenger" under the law.

The Legal Definition of a "Passenger"

According to the Department of Transportation, children and infants are considered passengers for the purpose of HOV lane regulations. This means that even if your car’s only other occupant is an infant, you are legally allowed to use the HOV lane. The intention behind this rule is straightforward: infants, like any other passengers, contribute to the number of occupants in the vehicle, thus fulfilling the requirement for HOV lane use.

However, this seemingly simple rule becomes more complex when considering the case of unborn babies.

Do Unborn Babies Count?

In 2022, a Texas woman made headlines when she argued that her unborn baby should count as a passenger, allowing her to use the HOV lane. The situation arose after she was pulled over and the Dallas County sheriff's deputies issued a citation for driving alone in the HOV lane. 

Her defense was initially met with skepticism by the officers, but after considering the legal context—especially following the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade—a judge ultimately dismissed the ticket, agreeing that her unborn child could be considered a passenger. 

Although her citation was ultimately dismissed, Texas law has not been updated to reflect that an unborn baby is considered a passenger in the context of HOV lanes.

This raises a legal grey area: while children and infants are undoubtedly considered passengers, current laws generally do not recognize unborn babies as fulfilling the passenger requirement for HOV lanes.

In another, somewhat more straightforward case, a driver in Arizona was caught using a fake baby doll as her "second passenger" in the HOV lane. Unlike the previous situation, this case was a clear violation of the law, demonstrating that creative attempts to circumvent the rules can lead to both legal repercussions and public ridicule.

The Consequences of HOV Lane Violations

 Penalties for such violations vary by state, often resulting in fines ranging from $100 to $400. Repeat offenses can lead to even higher fines or additional legal complications.

Understanding the Importance of Traffic Laws

HOV lanes play a critical role in managing traffic flow and encouraging environmentally-friendly carpooling. Adhering to these regulations is essential for ensuring road safety and efficiency. Misusing these lanes not only undermines their purpose but also disrupts traffic patterns, leading to increased congestion and potential accidents.

Know the Law Before You Hit the HOV Lane

While children and infants are recognized as passengers for the purposes of HOV lanes, unborn babies are not yet legally considered passengers in most jurisdictions. It’s important to understand and respect these laws to avoid costly penalties and to contribute to safer, more efficient roadways.

To learn more about this, check out my video. For more legal insights and to stay informed on similar topics, head over to our YouTube channel. Don’t forget to like and follow for more updates!